Why Silicone Costs More, and Why That Is Not a Markup
Share
Quick answer
Silicone costs more because it is a two-component material that has to be cured under controlled conditions, it cannot be recycled into new product, and it lasts years instead of months. A porous TPE item is cheaper to make, degrades faster, and is usually replaced several times over the life of one silicone item.
Key takeaways
- Silicone costs more because it is a two-component cured material with higher reject rates than moulded TPE.
- TPE is porous and typically replaced within months; silicone is non-porous and lasts years.
- A $20 item replaced every three months costs around $240 over three years; a $99.99 silicone item costs $99.99 once.
- Price and material are separate axes: an expensive porous item is still porous.
- If a brand charges a premium without naming the material, the premium is probably not the material.
When two products look similar and one costs four times more, the instinct is to assume a markup. In this category the difference is usually the material, and the material determines how many times you buy.
What makes silicone more expensive to produce?
Silicone is a two-component material: a base and a curing agent, mixed in a precise ratio and cured under controlled heat. Getting that wrong produces a batch that is tacky, weak, or uneven. The process is slower than moulding TPE and it produces more rejects.
TPE is a thermoplastic. It melts and re-forms, which makes it fast and cheap to mould, and it can be reground and reused. That is the core of the price difference, before branding enters the picture.
How long does each material actually last?
| TPE (porous) | Silicone (non-porous) | |
|---|---|---|
| Typical replacement | Every few months | Years |
| Why it fails | Absorbs residue, surface goes tacky | Physical damage, or motor failure |
| Can it be repaired | No | No, but it does not need to be |
What is the three-year cost?
A $20 porous item replaced every three months is twelve purchases over three years: about $240. A $99.99 silicone item bought once is $99.99. The silicone item is cheaper by roughly $140, and it is one purchase instead of twelve.
This only holds if the silicone item is cared for. Storing it damp or boiling it with a motor inside will shorten its life regardless of material.
Is the more expensive option always silicone?
No. Price and material are separate axes. An $80 porous item is still porous. The way to check is to read the material line, not the price, and to smell the product if you can.
If a brand charges a premium and does not state the material, that is a signal about what the premium is for.
What are you actually paying for?
Three things: the raw material, the curing process, and the fact that it does not need replacing. Everything else — packaging, finish, branding — is secondary to those three.
When the material is stated plainly on the page, the price usually makes sense. When it is not stated, the price is a guess.
Why does the same material vary so much in price?
Two silicone products at very different prices can both be silicone. The difference is then the grade, the wall thickness, the finish, the motor, and the brand. Material sets a floor on the price, not a ceiling.
The useful comparison is not "silicone versus silicone" but "how long will each last and what does a year of use cost".
What does medical grade actually add?
Medical grade refers to a silicone formulation that has been tested for body contact and produced to a documented standard. It costs more because of testing and traceability, not because the chemistry is fundamentally different.
For a body-contact product it is a reasonable thing to pay for. It is not the only thing worth paying for.
Where does the discount change the maths?
A discount moves the three-year comparison but does not reverse it unless it is very large. At $99.99 down from $158, the silicone item still costs less per year than a $20 item replaced four times a year.
What the discount really changes is the risk. Buying once at a lower price is a comfortable decision; buying once at full price requires more confidence in the material.
What if you only want to spend $20?
Then buy the porous product and replace it on schedule. That is a coherent choice. The mistake is spending $80 on a porous product because the price implied quality — the material is unchanged by the price.
Price is a signal about the seller. Material is a signal about the product.
How long does the premium take to pay back?
For most people, within the first year. If a porous item is replaced every three months, the fourth purchase lands around the twelve-month mark, and that is the point at which the silicone item has already paid for itself.
After that the comparison only widens, because the silicone item keeps working and the porous one keeps being replaced. The premium is not a luxury markup — it is prepaying for years of use.
The one condition is care. Storing it damp or boiling it with a motor inside will end its life early regardless of what it cost, which is why the care routine matters as much as the material choice.
Frequently asked questions
Is an expensive product always silicone?
No. Price tracks brand, packaging and features as much as material. The material line on the listing is the only reliable indicator, and smelling the product confirms it.
Why does TPE feel softer than silicone?
TPE is formulated to be very soft and stretchy, which is part of why it feels cheaper and degrades faster. Silicone can be soft too, but it holds its shape and does not go tacky.
Does silicone ever need replacing?
Not because of the material itself. It gets replaced when the surface is torn, when it becomes tacky, or when a motor stops holding a charge.
Is medical grade silicone different?
It refers to a grade of silicone formulated and tested for body contact. It is still silicone; the grade describes testing and purity rather than a different material.
Sources
- U.S. Food and Drug Administration — Medical Devices
- PubMed — peer-reviewed literature index
- ACOG — Women's Health FAQs
Editorial note: AI-assisted educational content. Product care and buying information only. Not medical advice.